Deltoro v. McMullen, 322 S.C. 328, 471 S.E.2d 742 (Ct.App.1996), is a published May 1996 opinion from the South Carolina Court of Appeals.  It is the only published opinion from the South Carolina appellate courts which was an outright defeat for my client.

The case involved the right of the South Carolina family court to modify a Virginia child support order against a Virginia resident (Mr. McMullen).  After the family court modified his Virginia child support order, he retained me to handle his appeal.

On appeal, for the first time, Mr. McMullen raised the issue of the South Carolina family court’s lack subject matter jurisdiction to modify a Virginia child support order.  The appeal turned on whether to apply the Uniform Reciprocal Enforcement of Support Act (URESA) or the recently enacted Uniform Interstate Family Support Act (UIFSA).  Modification of foreign support orders where the other party still lived in the using state was allowed under URESA; it was not allowed under UIFSA.  UIFSA was enacted after Ms. Deltoro filed her support modification case but before the case went to trial.

Initially, the Court of Appeals reversed the family court’s decision, holding that under UIFSA the family court did not have jurisdiction to modify Mr. McMullen’s child support obligation.  Ms. Deltoro’s attorney then sought rehearing, arguing (correctly) that, due to a savings clause, jurisdiction attached under URESA at the time of filing and remained throughout the case.

This appeal was part of the inspiration for my first published article on family law: Creating or Defeating South Carolina Jurisdiction in Multi-State Custody or Support Cases

Put Mr. Forman’s experience, knowledge, and dedication to your service for any of your South Carolina family law needs.

Recent Blog Posts

The Folly of Fighting Child Protective Services after a Merits Finding

Early in my career, when family court attorneys were still being court appointed to represent indigent parents in abuse and neglect proceedings, I

[ + ] Read More

Court of Appeals determines homosexual couples could not enter common law marriage prior to the Condon case

A July 1, 2020, Court of Appeals opinion in Swicegood v. Thomson determined that South Carolina code prohibited homosexual couples from forming the

[ + ] Read More

College related child care is not work-related child care for the purpose of setting child support

There are a number of South Carolina family court opinions that are of narrow relevance but of significant importance when relevant. Such cases

[ + ] Read More